The Weekly Wrap-Up provides summaries of recent publications from the Spin-Off Report including links to the full-length research reports. If you haven’t engaged with the research over the past seven days, the Weekly Wrap-Up will quickly update you on our newest and highest conviction ideas.
Newest Publications & Updates
COMPREHENSIVE REPORT: Kellogg Co. (NYSE: K)
August 16, 2023
- On June 21, 2022, Kellogg Co. (NYSE: K) announced that its Board of Directors approved a plan to separate the company into three standalone, publicly traded companies. The separation, which was posited to be completed via tax-free spin-offs, would have resulted in shareholders of record owning interests in, as referenced at the time of the announcement, “Global Snacking Co.,” “North America Cereal Co.,” and “Plant Co.” In February 2023, in conjunction with the company’s 2022 year-end results, K announced that it now plans to retain its plant-based business while spinning off just its North America cereal business. In terms of timing, management is currently targeting the spin-off to be completed by year-end 2023, subject to customary closing conditions including the final approval from the Board of Directors, an effectiveness declaration of the company’s Form 10 filing by the SEC, and receipt of a private letter ruling from the IRS in respect to the tax-free nature of the transaction, amongst others.
- The spin company will control the North American Cereal business, adopt the corporate moniker WK Kellogg Co. and intends to trade on the NYSE under the symbol “KLG.” The parent company, a global snack-focused business, will change its name to Kellanova following the separation and continue to trade on the NYSE under the ticker “K.”
- Management’s stated rationale for the separation largely hinges on the idea that it believes that Kellanova’s growth and margin profile has been obfuscated withing the current conglomerate structure. Following the separation, Kellanova’s superior revenue growth and margins, relative to WK Kellogg’s, will be more apparent to investors, while WK Kellogg’s dedicated sales force and management, combined with its independent balance sheet, will allow management to make investments in its supply chain to expand margins.
- In theory, upon the separation, the snacks-focused growth company with higher margins should be re-rated to a higher valuation multiple while the cereal company will likely be re-rated lower. Interestingly, with K currently trading at 11.0x 2024 estimates, it approximates that of WK Kellog peers. However, given the spin company’s margin profile and goal of “stabilized” sales, the shares will trade at a discount to the group.
- On a pre-spin, sum-of-the-parts basis, we fairly value shares of Kellogg Co. at $73 per share, consisting of $3.50 per share in value from WK Kellog and approximately $70 per share in value from Kellanova. With shares trading at 11.0x the current 2024 consensus EBITDA estimate, current negative volume trends across the business, and the impending separation, combined with the implied upside to our fair value estimate, we view it as prudent to rate shares of K at NEUTRAL ahead of the expected 4Q spin-off of WK Kellogg.
- While we do not see a pre-spin opportunity, we do anticipate the potential for post-separation investment opportunities, depending on the ultimate initial trading range of Kellanova and WK Kellogg. Of primary interest would be if WK Kellogg experiences an initial sell-off of shares due to investors exiting the spin company ownership position in favor of maintaining a position in the more growth oriented, geographically diversified snacks company, which should pressure shares of WK Kellogg in initial trading. Additionally, given the relative estimated market capitalizations of the post-spin company’s it should be expected that WK Kellogg will not be included in the S&P 500 (K is currently a constituent and we would expect Kellanova to remain in the index), which would also create indiscriminate/forced selling by indexed investors. If shares of WK Kellogg trade at a significant discount, investors may see an opportunity to invest in a “classic spin-off” where an “unloved” and underinvested entity is able to significantly improve operations and offer significant out sized returns over the longer term. Given a separate management, focused sales force, and an independent balance sheet, if management were to successfully widen margins to approximate that of peers and delever following the investment phase, WK Kellogg could show significant earnings growth potential in the out years.
The European Spin-Off Report – Novartis AG (NOVN SW, NYSE: NVS) – FLASH
August 18, 2023
Novartis to Spin-Off Sandoz on or about October 4, 2023
- On August 18, Novartis AG (NOVN SW, NYSE: NVS) announced the company had filed a shareholder information brochure in relation to a proposed spin-off of its generic drug business, Sandoz. NOVN will hold an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) on September 15, 2023, at which time investors will vote to approve the posited spin-off. If completed, the separation would be accomplished via a dividend in kind whereby NOVN shareholders of record would receive one share of Sandoz for every five shares of NOVN. The Sandoz spin-off is planned to occur on or around October 4, 2023, with a primary listing on the SIX Swiss Exchange, and an American Depositary Receipt (ADR) program in the U.S.
- In 2022, NOVN generated $50.5 billion in revenue and $16.7 billion in core operating income, as compared to $51.6 billion and $16.6 billion in the prior year. As the company currently stands, NOVN reports under two segments: Innovative Medicines, which contributed $41.3 billion in revenue in 2022, and Sandoz, which registered sales of $9.2 billion in 2022.
- Innovative Medicines focuses on development and marketing of novel medicines and includes treatments for cardiovascular, immunology, neuroscience, solid tumors, and hematology. Well known products include Cosentyx (marketed for psoriasis) and Entresto (chronic heart failure). Year-over-year Innovative Medicines revenue declined by 2% in 2022 as significant growth from cardiovascular products, in particular 31% growth in revenue from Entresto, was offset by generic competition for the segments more established brands (Afinito/Votubia and Gilenya). Through 1H 2023 segment revenue increased by 5% on key product strength (Entresto, Kesimpta, Pluvicto, and Kisqali), which was partly offset by generic competition. Generic competition lowered revenue grew by 5 percentage points, while pricing added an additional 3 percentage point headwind. Core operating margins widened to 36.9% in 1H 2023 versus 36.2% in 1H 2022.
- Sandoz controls NOVN’s portfolio of generic pharmaceuticals and biosimilars. Sandoz revenue decreased by 4% in 2022 and operating income declined by 8% as higher investments to generate sales and inflationary costs reduced margins to 20.6% versus 21.4% in the prior year. Through 1H 2023 sales increased 4%, largely on strength in Europe on products regionally launched within the prior 12 months, which was partially offset by pricing. Sandoz 1H 2023 core operating profit declined by 2% as margins were 19.6% versus 21.2% in 1H 2022.
- The separations of generics from “Innovative Medicines” follows an industry trend where pharmaceutical manufacturers separate out the lower margin and in general revenue declining generics businesses from the higher margin, higher growth potential, yet involving higher R&D expense, proprietary development businesses. Following the separation, the parent company will optically have an improved growth and margin profile, while the spin company’s dedicated capital structure will allow it to pursue attractive off-patent opportunities and return capital to shareholders.
- In conjunction with NOVN’s 1H 2023 results, management updated its full year 2023 guidance to include Innovative Medicines sales growth of high single digit, and core operating income increase of low single digit to mid-teens (includes corporate expenses and excludes Sandoz contribution). Sandoz sales are expected to increase by mid-single digits, and core operating income to decline in the low double-digit range based on standalone company costs and continued inflationary pressures.
- Notably, in terms of rationale, specialty pharmaceutical companies trade at a premium to generic manufacturers. NOVN currently trades at 11.6x forward EBITDA, which is roughly in line with peers such as Pfizer Inc. (NYSE: PFE) and Merck & Co. Inc. (NYSE: MRK), while generic manufacturers such as Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd. (NYSE: TEVA) trade at closer to 7.0x forward EBITDA. As such following the separation it should be expected that the parent company would not see a large degree of multiple expansion, while the generics company would likely experience multiple contraction top approximate peers.
- Based on 1H 2023 results, and managements guidance, we forecast that as standalone companies, Sandoz and Novartis (ex-Sandoz) will generate $1.9 billion and $17.7 billion in respective EBITDA during 2023. Valuing Sandoz at 7.0x and Novartis at 12.0x, implies post-separation enterprise values of $13.1 billion and $212.7 billion. Incorporating current net debt and diluted shares outstanding, as well as the current USD/CHF exchange rate, we preliminarily assign a pre-spin fair value estimate of CHF 92.00 per share to NOVN SW.
Radar Screen – August 2023
Monthly publication providing ongoing analysis on companies where we see potential for a value-unlocking event
Companies discussed this month: Alphabet Inc. (GOOG), APi Group Corp. (APG), California Resources Corp. (CRC), Carrier Global Corp. (CARR), Crown Holdings Inc. (CCK), FLEETCOR Technologies, Inc. (FLT), Goodyear Tire & Rubber, Inc. (FLT), Enhabit Inc. (EHAB), Hasbro, Inc. (HAS), IAC Inc. (IAC), Liberty Broadband Corp. (LBRDK), Matthews International Corp. (MATW), PAR Technology Corp. (PAR), RCI Hospitality Inc. (RICK), Stanley Black & Decker (SWK), Tiptree Inc. (TIPT), Western Digital Corp. (WDC)
Spin-Off Report Calendar – August 2023
Published monthly, The Spin-Off Calendar provides one-page summaries of every spin-off under coverage from the announcement date, followed by the filing of the Form 10 and continuing 60 days post completion.
Spin-Off Report Compendium – August 2023
Murray Stahl’s commentary on various investing themes and single stock recommendations.
European Spin-Off Compendium – April 2023
Murray Stahl’s commentary on various investing themes and single stock recommendations in Europe.
Bits & Pieces – August 2023
Covers mispriced stub securities, tracking stocks and other arbitrage opportunities.
Product Specialist
Rich Albanese
ralbanese@pcsresearchgroup.com
+1 646-839-5566