On December 8, 2010, Fortune Brands (NYSE: FO) announced that its Board of Directors had approved the tax-free spin-off of its home and security consumer products business and that it was examining the potential sale or tax-free spin-off of its golf products business. Although there is no definitive timeframe for these transactions, the company stated that it intends to finalize its separation plans within the next several months, with a view to effecting both divestitures soon thereafter.
The home and security business is a domestic leader in a variety of branded consumer products, including: faucets, cabinets, entry-doors, windows, padlocks and related security products, and home-storage products. To the extent that the US housing market recovers going forward, this business could become much more profitable, as evidenced by the segment’s 2006 revenue of $4.7 billion and operating income of $700 million, excluding its share of consolidated corporate expenses, which is almost three times more than the segment’s 2010 annualized operating income of $240 million.
The golf products business is a worldwide leader in the manufacture and sale of golf balls, clubs, shoes, gloves, bags, outerwear, and accessories. This segment’s current annualized revenue and operating income is approximately $1.3 billion and $150 million (excluding corporate expenses), respectively.
Following the completion of the home and security spin-off and the divestiture, either through a sale or a spin-off, of the golf business, Fortune Brands would become a pure-play, distilled spirits company with a leadership position in bourbon, as well as a global participation in whiskey, tequila, cognacs, and other liquors. The company’s brands include Jim Beam, Maker’s Mark, Knob Creek, Canadian Club, Laphroaig, Teacher’s Highland, Sauza, Hornitos, El Tesoro, Courvoisier, and DeKuyper. Annualized revenue and operating income for the year within the spirit segment is approximately $2.5 billion and $505 million (excluding corporate expenses), respectively.
Management indicated that the underlying reason for the separation of its three businesses is to help maximize shareholder value. However, there appears to be little upside in the short-term, as comparable companies trade at par or at a discount to Fortune Brands’ current consolidated EV/2011E EBITDA multiple of almost 11x. Spirits companies trade at 11x their 2011 EBITDA estimates, while golf product companies trade at approximately 6x EBITDA, and home consumer products companies trade at approximately 10x EBITDA. Following a share price appreciation of over 60% since early July 2010, it appears that the shares of Fortune Brands have priced in any type of valuation discrepancy that may have existed as a result of the company’s conglomerate structure. There does appear to be a long-term investment thesis surrounding these businesses, however, as the spirits and home and security segments are currently performing well below the peak earnings that were realized in healthier economic environments.