Menu
Home Our Team Sample Research Client Portal Contact Client Portal Login

FLASH: D.E Master Blenders 1753 to Begin ˜Regular Way Trading On June 29, 2012, Fair Value Estimate Revised

On May 31, 2012, Sara Lee Corporation (NYSE: SLE) announced that the company’s board of directors approved the spin-off of its international coffee and tea business, CoffeeCo. Following the spin-off, CoffeeCo will immediately merge with D.E Master Blenders 1753, an Amsterdam holding company. D.E Master Blenders 1753 shares will trade on the NYSE Euronext in Amsterdam under the symbol DE. In conjunction with the spin-off SLE shareholders as of the record date June 14, 2012, will receive a $3.00 per share special dividend. The transactions are expected to occur after the close on June 28, 2012, with ‘regular way’ trading of SLE and DE commencing on June 29, 2012. Shares of SLE will begin trading ‘ex-distribution’ and shares of DE will begin trading on a ‘when-issued’ basis on June 12, 2012. SLE shareholders as of the record date will receive one share of D.E Master Blenders 1753 for every one share of SLE owned. The SEC must still declare the registration statement effective. The company has received a favorable ruling from the IRS regarding the tax-free status of the CoffeeCo spin-off.

Following the transactions SLE will conduct a 1-for-5 reverse stock split. As noted in our initial Sara Lee Spin-Off Report (April 20, 2012), the fair value calculation would be adjusted based on the finalized distribution ratio, capital structure, dividend policy and changes in company/industry fundamentals. The adjustments to the initial calculation to account for the post-spin reverse stock split are shown in the attached FLASH. The post-spin fair value estimate of SLE is revised to $34 per share. The fair value estimates for pre-spin SLE of $20 and post-spin DE of €8, or $10, remain unchanged.

Please see the Sara Lee Corporation Spin-Off Report, dated April 20, 2012, for further details.

FLASH: Sara Lee Board of Directors Approves Tax-Free Spin-Off to Separate Business Into Two Publicly Traded Companies

On January 28, 2011, Sara Lee Corp. (NYSE: SLE) announced that its Board of Directors had approved a tax-free spin-off to separate its business into two publicly traded companies. The parent company will consist of its North American retail and food service operations, which manufacture, market, and sell a variety of meat-based and dessert products, and will retain the Sara Lee corporate name. The spin company will consist of the International Beverages business, which sells a variety of coffee- and tea-based products throughout mostly Europe, Australia, and South America. The spin company will be named D.E Master Blenders 1753 and will be listed on the NYSE Euronext in Amsterdam. In conjunction with the spin-off, the company intends to declare a $3 per share special dividend, funded largely through the already completed sale of its North American bakery business. The company’s Form F-1 has been declared effective by the SEC, and the IRS has given SLE a favorable ruling on the tax-free status of the transaction. The transaction requires no further approval. Share distribution and capital structures have yet to be finalized. The transaction is expected to be completed in 1H 2012.

The transaction appears to be the last step in a business transformation that has taken more than five years. The sale of non-core businesses and the separation into two pure-play companies may attract a more focused shareholder base for each entity. However, the international listing of D.E Master Blenders 1753 may inject volatility into that stock’s initial trading.

The remaining SLE businesses have had difficulty in recent years driving sales and margin expansion, as increased prices to offset higher commodity costs were met with reduced demand. Management plans relaunches of products, increased advertising, and a more rational pricing strategy to help kick start sales. Given previous interest from both strategic and financial suitors, post-spin-off SLE may be an attractive target, especially in light of what could be considered an underlevered balance sheet. Incorporating the potential of a takeout, a fair value estimate of $7 per share can be derived.

D.E Master Blenders 1753, on the other hand, appears to be decently positioned in what is an attractive global growth industry. Secular trends showing an increasing consumer preference for single-serve coffee options present opportunities for management to grow revenue above historical industry levels and to widen margins. Coffee companies in general have benefited from these trends, with investors awarding outsized valuation multiples. Following the spin-off transaction, if shares of D.E Master Blenders 1753 were valued in line with peers, a fair value estimate of $10 per share could be derived.

It should be noted that given the listing of D.E Master Blenders 1753 in Amsterdam, there is a potential for forced selling by investors who cannot, or choose not to, own foreign listed securities. Initial trading at a significant discount to the $10 per share fair value estimate may represent an attractive buying opportunity.

Using a sum-of-the-parts valuation, a fair value estimate of $20 for pre-spin shares of Sara Lee can be derived, consisting of $7 for post-spin SLE, $10 for D.E Master Blenders 1753, and including the $3 per share special dividend to be declared in conjunction with the spin-off. Given an absence of likely upside from current levels, shares of SLE are not recommended for purchase ahead of the transaction.

FLASH: MeadWestvaco Expects to Complete Separation of Office Products Segment on May 1, 2012

On April 13, 2012, MeadWestvaco (NYSE: MWV) announced that it intends to complete the spin-off of its consumer and office products (C&OP) business on May 1, 2012. Upon completion of the spin-off, C&OP will immediately merge with ACCO Brands Corporation (NYSE: ABD) in a Reverse Morris Trust transaction, whereby MWV shareholders of record on April 24, 2012, will receive 0.33 shares of ABD for every share of MWV owned. Following the merger, MWV shareholders will own 50.5% of the new ACCO. In addition, MWV announced that it had received a favorable private letter ruling from the Internal Revenue Service in regard to the tax free status of the spin-off transaction. In conjunction with the merger of the C&OP business with ACCO Brands, the ticker symbol will change to ‘ACCO’ (from ABD) on the NYSE.

ACCO shareholders still must approve the merger with Mead’s C&OP business at a special meeting on April 23, 2012. If the merger is approved, shares of MWV and ACCO are expected to begin trading on a ‘when-issued’ basis on April 24, 2012. As noted in the initial MeadWestvaco Spin-Off Report and subsequent FLASH (March 12, 2012), following the spin-off of the C&OP business, initial trading of MWV is expected at $27 per share. Given global growth prospects for the packaging industry, near-term upside is likely limited. However investors with a longer-term time horizon may arrive at a $39 per share fair value estimate. Shares of ACCO Brands Corporation are expected to trade at an initial value of $11 per share following ACCO’s merger with the C&OP business, near the current price of the pre-merger stock. Please see the MeadWestvaco FLASH, dated March 12, 2012, for further details.

FLASH: Post-spin Fair Value Estimate for Phillips 66 Raised to $30 per Share (from $24)

The Spin-Off Report fair value estimate for Phillips 66 is raised to $30 per share (from $24) following the investor update on April 9, 2012, which highlighted opportunities in its midstream and chemical operations. ConocoPhillips (NYSE: COP) is separating its refining, marketing, midstream and chemicals operations into Phillips 66. The stock will begin ‘regular-way’ trading on the NYSE under the ticker ‘PSX’ on May 1, 2012. The parent will retain the exploration and production (E&P) assets. ‘When-issued’ trading of PSX is likely to commence around April 12. COP has received all regulatory approvals.

As noted in the ConocoPhillips Spin-Off Report, dated January 26, 2012, the fair value estimate for the spin-off would be reconsidered after the capital structure, and share distribution were finalized, amended Form 10s were filed, and management provided a pre-separation operations update.

The fair value for the parent post-spin remains unchanged at $62 per share, while the fair value estimate for PSX is raised to $30 per share (from $24), based on a 1:2 share distribution for the spin-off entity. Previously the valuation was based entirely on historic and relative multiples in the refining sector. But management confirmed during an April 2012 operations update that a greater percentage of future capital would be allotted to the more stable chemicals and midstream businesses. Future expenditures in the refining business would focus on efforts to lifts spreads not capacity. As a result, one might consider a sum-of-the-parts approach when reaching a fair value estimate. One may expect a certain post-spin discount as earnings from the chemicals and midstream segments are generated overwhelmingly from joint ventures, which arguably creates greater uncertainty and less transparency. Although notably the two large COP joint ventures, CPChem and DCP Midstream, are each more than a decade old.

The $30 per share post-spin valuation is also supported by considering the dividend yield of the refiner and midstream peer groups. Refiners Marathon Petroleum Corp. (NYSE: MPC), which less than a year ago was spun-off from Marathon Oil (NYSE: MRO) and Valero Energy Corp. (NYSE: VLO), which has a similar margin performance as the future PSX each trade at around a 2.4% dividend yield, while non-MLP (master limited partnership) midstream companies, including Kinder Morgan Inc. (NYSE: KMI), Williams Companies (NYSE: WMB) and ONEOK Inc. (NYSE: OKE) have yields averaging 3.0%. Using a range of yields between 2.4% and 3.0% for PSX and a proposed dividend of $0.80 per share results in a $30 per share initial post-transaction valuation (see exhibit in attachment). While cash flow generation from refineries can be volatile, more stable revenue generation from the other businesses should help offset. Over the last two years, free cash flow (cash flow from operations minus capital expenditures) has averaged about $2.5 billion, more than ample to cover the proposed $512 million needed for an $0.80 dividend and leave cash available to buy back stock.

The sum-of-the parts valuation considers the three PSX business segments separately. The valuation for the refining business is based on a multiple to daily processing capacity compared to other refiners with similar margins (such as Valero). The average income attributable to PSX over the last three-years from its chemicals operations is compared to multiples to trailing 12-month earnings for similar chemicals companies, such as LyondellBasell NV( NYSE: LYB). A 20% discount is applied given uncertainty and lack of transparency from the joint venture. Similarly the midstream average income attributable to PSX over the last three years is compared to multiples to trailing 12-month earnings for other midstream companies with associated MLPs: KMI, OKE and WMB. The same 20% discount is applied. The resulting $30 per share post-spin valuation is shown in the attached exhibit.

FLASH: Tyco International Flow Control to Merge with Pentair in Reverse Morris Trust Transaction…

On March 28, 2012, Tyco International (NYSE: TYC) announced plans to merge its Flow Control business with Pentair Inc. (NYSE: PNR) in an all-stock deal that will be structured as a Reverse Morris Trust, thus maintaining the tax-free status of the transaction. Tyco shareholders will own approximately 52.5% of the company to be named Pentair, while PNR shareholders will own approximately 47.5%. The new company will assume $275 million in net debt from Tyco’s Flow Control. Including debt and minority interest, and based on yesterday’s closing prices, the deal values Flow Control at about $4.9 billion. The CEO of Pentair is expected to lead the combined entity. New Pentair is estimated to generate annual sales of about $7.7 billion and will be an industry leader in valves and assorted products for energy, water, infrastructure and industrial usage. The transaction still requires regulatory and shareholder approval.

The deal follows the September 2011 announcement by Tyco to separate into three publicly-traded companies: (1) ADT North American Residential, which designs, installs and maintains home security systems, (2) Flow Control, (3) Commercial Fire and Security, which manufactures commercial fire and retail security systems. The separation is still scheduled for completion by the end of September 2012. Capital and liability allocations are yet to be finalized for the two remaining pieces. The spin-off of ADT will require SEC approval, an affirmative IRS ruling and is subject to a shareholder vote. TYC CEO Ed Breen will become non-executive chairman of the commercial fire and security business, and a consultant to the ADT business. At the time of the announcement, it was expected that the three entities (including Flow Control) would initially pay a dividend, which in sum was equal to TYC’s current $1.00 annual payment.

ADT North America generated pro forma estimated sales of $3.1 billion in F2011, while Commercial Fire and Safety contributed $10.2 billion. The ADT business will control approximately 26% of the U.S. home security market. North American revenue and consolidated segment operating margins have generally been trending higher since 2009. The commercial portion of ADT will remain with the parent, which will include the Commercial Fire and Security business.

The ADT business does not have a pure-play publicly traded comparable as it did acquire competitor Broad View Security (formerly Brinks Home Security) in 2010 for 3.3x 2010 estimated sales, or 9.5x 2010 estimated EBITDA. Applying a 3.3x multiple to 2011E ADT sales, one could arrive at an enterprise value of $10.2 billion.

The parent company, Commercial Fire and Security, could be compared to MSA Worldwide (NYSE: MSA), which currently trades at a 1.5x EV/sales multiple. Applying that multiple to the remaining business would result in an EV of $15.3 billion. Based on this sum-of-the-parts valuation, one could arrive at an EV of $30.4 billion, representing modest upside to the current EV of $27.8 billion.

FLASH: Expect MWV to Trade $27 Per Share Post Spin, Macro Concerns Limit Near-Term Upside

Following the spin-off of its consumer and office products business (C&OP), initial trading of MeadWestvaco (NYSE:MWV) is expected at $27 per share. Given global growth prospects for the packaging industry, near-term upside is likely limited. However investors with a longer-term time horizon may arrive at a $39 per share fair value estimate. Shares of ACCO Brands Corporation (NYSE:ABD) are expected to trade at an initial value of $11 per share following ABD’s merger with the C&OP business. The spin-off of MWV’s C&OP business, and subsequent merger of that business with ABD, is expected to take place in June 2012.

Given consensus estimate growth rates for sales of 2.3% and EBITDA growth of 4% for MWV’s peer group in 2012, and GDP growth forecasts for advanced nations of just 2.8%, according to The Conference Board, the parent stock is likely to trade at a lower range in the near term prior to approaching a $39 per share level in a stronger economic environment. The loss of the higher-margin C&OP business and increased focus on the commoditized packaging business may make it difficult to generate sales growth and margins in line with management’s annual expectations (discussed below) in the near term. In fact, management commented on its latest conference call of weakness in demand in North America and Europe, which it expects to last at least through 1H 2012.

The initial trading value estimate of $27 per share may be reached by subtracting the implied value of the C&OP business from MWV’s current valuation (see exhibit in attachment). However, an investor with a longer time horizon may still receive an acceptable return given management’s stated goals. Management has committed to maintaining the current $1.00 per share annual dividend following the transaction, which yields 3.2% at the current stock price. Second, management targets earnings growth of 7% to 10% annually for the parent post spin, consisting of approximately 5% revenue growth and 50 to 100 basis points of margin expansion.

At a minimum, the 3.2% dividend yield should provide a degree of support for MWV’s share price post spin given the relative attractiveness versus the current S&P 500’s yield of 2.0%. If MeadWestvaco can grow EBITDA at the low end of management range, a longer-term fair value estimate in three years of $39 per share can be derived assuming a constant valuation multiple (see exhibit in attachment), which is currently in line with peers. If it is assumed that the $1.00 per share annual dividend remains constant, and the stock rises from the immediate post-spin price of $27 to $39 within three years, total return would approach 56%, representing an approximate 16% CAGR over the three-year period.

FLASH: ConocoPhillips Sets Tentative Separation Dates

ConocoPhillips (NYSE: COP) expects Phillips 66, the spin-off entity that includes the company’s refining, marketing, midstream and chemicals operations, will begin ‘regular-way’ trading on the NYSE under the ticker ‘PSX’ on May 1, 2012. The transaction still requires SEC approval and an IRS private letter ruling on the tax-free status of the distribution. The Conoco board is scheduled to approve the separation at a meeting on April 4. Five days later, Phillips 66 management will provide an update on the spin-off entity’s operations. At that time, The Spin-Off Report’s fair value estimate may be reconsidered. ‘When-issued’ trading of PSX is likely to commence around April 12 with a record date for shareholders to receive the stock distribution set for April 16.

When considering a variety of relative- and absolute-value metrics and methodologies, an investor may conclude that COP is currently fairly valued on a sum-of-the-parts calculation. A lack of investment in recent years has resulted in relatively weak refiner margins, and COP has idled facilities with the intent to sell or close certain older, less competitive facilities. However, an investor may find an opportunity post separation in the E&P business once it is no longer saddled with the volatile and capital-intensive refining operations. COP has bought back 15% of its stock over the last three years and is committed to continuing to buy back stock and raise dividends in the future. Following the cash distribution from the spin-off, COP should be well positioned to develop liquids-rich assets, make targeted acquisitions to build proved reserves, and/or lift the dividend. One may reach fair value estimates of $62 post-spin for COP and a fair value estimate of $24 (following a 1:2 share distribution) for PSX. Please see the ConocoPhillips Spin-Off Report, dated January 26, 2012, for further details.

FLASH: Sara Lee Corporation Confirms $3 Per Share Special Dividend With Spin-Off of International Coffee and Tea Business

Sara Lee Corporation (SLE) announced that the spin-off of its international coffee and tea business is expected to be completed by late June 2012. The entity, temporarily known as DE Holdings International, will be domiciled in Amsterdam. The company has applied for a listing on NYSE Euronext. In addition the company confirmed the previously disclosed $3 per share special dividend will be paid to SLE shareholders at the time of the spin-off. Following the transaction, deferred tax liabilities of $700 million will be released. At the time of the spin-off, SLE expects to have $1.4 billion in net debt.

SLE has received a private letter ruling from the IRS confirming that the spin-off transaction will satisfy the key requirements for tax-free status. The announcement likely comes as a welcome to investors since the original spin-off was announced in January 2011. Following the transaction the parent company will be comprised of the North American retail and food service businesses, including the Sara Lee, Jimmy Dean, and Hillshire Farm brands. DE International will be comprised of the former international beverage segment.

The spin-off was originally announced on January 28, 2011, following drawn-out takeover discussions for one or both businesses. According to The Wall Street Journal, all of the offers fell below the $20 per share takeout price that would have been deemed acceptable by management

FLASH: Post Holdings’ Prospective Financial Information May Provide Initial Depressed Valuation,Attractive Investor Entry Point

On January 20, 2012, Ralcorp Holdings, Inc. (NYSE: RAH) released initial preliminary 1Q F2012 results and prospective financial information for the first twelve months following separation of Post Holdings Inc. (NYSE: POST). It appears that sales levels for Post have bottomed and management is expecting a slight return to growth following the separation. However, increased costs related to the spin-off and operations as a standalone company will likely result in lower EBITDA in the near term. If one were to approach valuing shares based on the mid-point of management estimates, and considering comparables’ earnings multiples, the stock may initially trade around $29 per share immediately following separation. This may provide an opportunistic entry point for value investors.

The Post business has been in decline for several years, with sales and margins suffering from a lack of demand and increased commodity costs. Given this, the Spin-Off Report fair value estimate of $43 for Post Holdings was derived using a F2013 EBITDA estimate of $265 million assuming that the POST business was reaching a trough and a return to EBITDA growth was reasonable after separation costs subsided.

The well-known brand portfolio and distribution network would appear to allow a quick rebound in sales upon the emergence of a stronger consumer. Also, the placement of a fair degree of debt on Post Holdings, levered at 4.3x projected net debt, would allow for a strong earnings rebound in a recovery mode. If shares begin trading at levels at or below $29, it would likely provide investors with an attractive entry point as management attempts to turn around the branded cereal business. Please see the Ralcorp Holdings Spin-Off Report, dated December 2, 2011, and follow up FLASH, dated January 17, 2012, for further details.

FLASH: Post Holdings to Begin ‘Regular Way’ Trading on February 6, 2012; Fair Value Estimate Revised

Shares of Post Holdings will be distributed after the bell on February 3, 2012, to Ralcorp Holdings, Inc. (NYSE: RAH) shareholders of record, as of the close of business on January 30, 2012. Post has been approved to trade on the NYSE under the ticker ‘POST’ following the separation. RAH shareholders will receive one share of POST for every two shares of RAH. The ‘when issued’ market for POST stock is expected to begin on January 26, 2012, with regular way trading expected to commence on February 6, 2012. The SEC still must declare effective the companies’ Registration Statement. The receipt of an IRS letter ruling on the tax-free status must be received to conclude the regulatory review.

As noted in our initial Ralcorp Holdings, Inc. Spin-Off Report (December 2, 2011), the fair value calculation would be adjusted based on the finalized distribution ratio, capital structure, dividend policy and changes in company/industry fundamentals. The fair value estimate was adjusted to reflect changes in the debt level and distribution made to the parent which were disclosed in an amended Form 10 containing the most recent quarterly data. Additionally the share distribution was set at 1:2. The adjustments to the initial calculations are shown on the next page.

The fair value estimate for initial trading in RAH is revised to $62, from $63 (see exhibit in attachment), based on the modestly adjusted cash distribution to the parent following the separation. If one were to assume 2012 revenue growth on par with 2011 with slight margin expansion, a fair value estimate of $67 per share appears to be reasonable within a 12-month time horizon.

Based on the revised capital structure, POST will incur a higher net debt position than previously estimated. Combined with the final share distribution of 1:2 versus the prior assumption of 1:1, POST shares can be assigned a fair value estimate of $43 versus the previous estimate of $28 (see exhibit in attachment). Investors with a longer time horizon and a more positive outlook on POST’s business prospects may see upside potential to $52. However this scenario is reliant on the company reversing its current negative earnings trends.