On December 3, 2020, International Paper (NYSE: IP) announced plans to spin off its Printing Papers business. The spin-off, which is expected to be tax-free to shareholders, is targeted to be completed late in the third quarter of 2021, subject to customary conditions including the declaration of effectiveness of the company’s Form 10 filing with the SEC. IP intends to retain a 19.9% stake in the spun-off company, with the expectation that IP will ultimately monetize its ownership position to provide incremental capital to the parent company. In conjunction with the spin-off, IP expects to reduce its current dividend ($2.05 per share) by 15%-20%, while the spin company is not expected to pay a dividend.
The spin company will adopt the corporate moniker Sylvamo Corp., which is derived from the Latin words “silva” and “amo”, being defined as “forest” and “love”, respectively. Sylvamo intends to list on the NYSE under the ticker “SLVM” and is expected to complete the separation on October 1, 2021, to shareholders of record as of September 15, 2021. When-issued trading in Sylvamo is expected to develop on or shortly before the record date.
IP shareholders of record will receive one share of SLVM for every 11 shares of IP held as of the record date. In conjunction with the spin-off, it is expected that Sylvamo will incur $1.5 billion in new debt, with net proceeds being distributed to IP.
As a standalone company, SLVM will derive almost 90% of its revenue from uncoated papers, including cut size printing, copy, and writing paper, as well as offset, envelope, and forms, among others. The remaining product revenue will be derived from Market Pulp (8% of 2020 revenue), used in making tissue, printing, writing, and specialty paper, and Coated Paperboard (3% of 2020 revenue), which is used in packaging for liquids and beverage containers.
With respect to rationale, the spin-off mainly accomplishes the separation of the structurally declining paper business from the more growth-oriented packaging and cellulose fibers business. Additionally, the lower debt leverage ratios at the parent company will give IP flexibility in pursuing both internal and non-organic growth opportunities that might have been more difficult to achieve with a more levered balance sheet. However, given the relative valuations of post-spin peers, the ultimate ability to unlock value will be derived from post-spin performance over the longer term, rather than realizing more immediate value via a rerating of shares. Thus, we do not view the separation of the two businesses as a catalyst to unlock near-term value and suggest, instead, that the post-spin parent company’s ability to drive revenue and earnings is the larger opportunity for shareholders.
We fairly value post-spin shares of Sylvamo at $67 per share. In our view, the secular trends in the paper market make investing in standalone Sylvamo a difficult proposition without a significant margin of safety to our fair value estimate. It can be expected that upon distribution, historical shareholders of IP would exit the position in Sylvamo and would favor holding the parent company in view of the growing market for the parent’s remaining business. Additionally, the impact of Sylvamo’s lack of a dividend should not be overlooked, as investment mandates may result in indiscriminate selling. According to Bloomberg, approximately 39% of IP shares outstanding are held within portfolios related to dividends. Further, at its estimated market capitalization, Sylvamo is not likely to be included in the S&P 500. Given IP’s retained 19.9% ownership stake in Sylvamo, and taking an average of valuation exercises, we fairly value shares of post-spin IP at $63 per share.
On a pre-spin basis, shares of International Paper Co. are fairly valued at $69 per share, consisting of approximately $61.50 in value from post-spin IP and approximately $7.50 in value from Sylvamo. Although our fair value estimate represents roughly 16% potential upside from the current share price, we assign a NEUTRAL rating to pre-spin IP. Our hesitancy to recommend pre-spin IP shares is rooted in the belief that shares of Sylvamo will likely come under selling pressure in initial trading, which would likely erase any near-term upside potential implied by our fair value estimate. Post-spin, we would favor the parent company’s prospects given the current demand dynamics and its ability to pass through price increases that are expected to largely offset higher costs for raw materials and transportation.