ALERT: IAC to Spin-Off Vimeo
On December 22, 2010, IAC/InteActiveCorp. (NASDAQ: IAC), before the market open, announced that the company’s Board of Directors has approved a plan to spin-off its Vimeo business. The transaction, which is expected to be tax-free to IAC and IAC shareholders, is targeted to be completed in 2Q 2021, contingent on shareholder approval at a stockholder meeting to be held in 1Q 2021, among other customary regulatory requirements.
IAC, a media and internet conglomerate with a long history of value-unlocking transactions (e.g., Expedia, LendingTree, Ticketmaster HSN and most recently Match) controls majority stakes in publicly-traded ANGI Homeservices (NASDAQ: ANGI), a digital marketplace for, among other things, home repair and maintenance. As well, IAC operates a variety of other privately held businesses, including Vimeo, Dotdash, Care.com (acquired in February 2020), Mosaic Group, The Daily Beast, Bluecrew, Ask Media, and IAC Films. (Note: IAC’s Chairman, Barry Diller, via his 100% ownership of the Class B common stock, controls more than 40% of the company’s voting power.)
Vimeo is a “global video platform that allows professional, small and medium sized business, organizations and enterprises to connect with their audiences, customers, and employees.” The platform is offered as a cloud based Software-as-a-Service (“SaaS”), which enables customers to create, host, stream, and monetize their video product across platforms and devices. Vimeo operates under the brand names Vimeo, Magisto (acquired in 2019), and Livestream (acquired in 2017).
In 2019, Vimeo generated $196 million in revenue (4.1% of IAC revenue including the since seperated Match Group revenue; 7.2% of revenue excluding Match) and generated an adjusted loss before interst, taxes, depreciation, and amortization of $41.8 million. 2019 Vimeo revenue increased 23% as subscribers increased by 30% in the year (to year end 1.2 million) and a 10% increase in revenue per subscriber (benefited from the mid-year Magisto acquisition). The 2019 loss was 49% higher than the prior year on increased marketing expenses. Through 3Q 2020 Vimeo operated with an adjusted EBITDA loss of $12.7 million. Of note, in 3Q 2020 Vimeo increased revenue by 44% as subscribers increased to 1.46 milllion and the business operated profitably on an adjusted EBITDA basis ($3.4 million in the quarter) for the first time.
As background of IAC’s historical seperation of subsidiaries and market commentary on future potential seperation, investors may note that in August 2019, IAC’s chief financial officer, Glenn Schiffman, indicated that the company had begun to explore the potential separation of MTCH and ANGI. Subsequently, in October 2019, the company indicated that a preliminary proposal for a tax-free separation of MTCH had been presented to the Board and that it would not further evaluate options for its ANGI stake until the aforementioned transaction is completed. More recently, in December 2019, the company formally announced that it would separate MTCH in a tax-free transaction that was completed on July 1, 2020. Presumably, the completion of that transaction, per IAC’s prior commentary, will allow management to turn its attention toward the potential separation of ANGI.
PRELIMINARY VALUATION
The company, as it stands today, operates under the following reported businesses: ANGI Homeowner services (IAC recognized $1.3 billion in revenue and $130.8 million in adjusted EBITDA through 3Q 2020), Search ($430.9 million in revenue and $34.4 million in adjusted EBITDA through 3Q 2020), Emerging & Other ($320.6 million in revenue and a loss of $30.6 million through 3Q 2020), Vimeo ($199.4 million in revenue and a loss of $12.7 million through 3Q 2020), and Dotdash ($19.5 million in revenue and $35.3 million in adjusted EBITDA through 3Q 2020). It should be noted that the current year to date individual business performances have been negatively impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic, in particular the ANGI business.
Following the separation, IAC will essentially become a holding company for the ownership position in ANGI Homeservices Inc. (NASDAQ: ANGI), with the remaining operating businesses having generated approximately $891 million in revenue and $39 million in adjusted EBITDA (prior to corporate expense of $115 million) through 3Q 2020.
In terms of valuing Vimeo, it is worth noting that in conjunction with IAC’s 3Q 2020 earnings release, it was disclosed the company had raised $150 million at Vimeo, which implied an enterprise value of approximately $2.75 billion for the subsidiary. We approach the valuation of pre-spin IAC on a sum-of-the-parts basis given its varying businesses and public holdings and view it as appropriate to present differing scenarios based on the individual business valuations. If shares were to be valued at the current share price of ANGI and Vimeo valued at the equity investment, including net cash of $2.5 billion, shares of IAC would be fairly valued at $125 per share, which likely is the lower end of where shares could potentially trade.
In a more forward-looking valuation, given equity investment are typically done at a discount to intrinsic value, the price paid could be extrapolated to future growth of Vimeo. The $2.8 billion implied valuation equates to roughly 14x 2019 revenue. Assuming Vimeo annual revenue growth of 25% through 2021, which is reasonable given the current growth trends, and applying a 14x multiple implies a Vimeo valuation of $4.3 billion. Incorporating this Vimeo valuation, and increasing the estimated share price for ANGI based on the current consensus target, implies a fair value estimate of $149 per share.
Lastly, we incorporate the remaining operating businesses within the parent. In 2019 these businesses generated $46.8 million in adjusted EBITDA (including corporate expense). Assuming a normalized market multiple of 11.0x, those operating businesses would be valued at roughly $515 million. Including these businesses into the fair value estimate would raise the FVE to $155 per share. Of note, in a more bullish scenario, which would include 10% EBITDA growth and a 16x multiple (inline with the current S&P forward multiple), the fair value estimate would increase to $160 per share.
Shares of IAC currently trade at $183.61 having increased near 15% in morning trading following the spin-off announcement. While we acknowledge that the assumptions laid out above can and should be challenged, we struggle to see significant value left to be unlocked over and above where shares are currently trading.