On July 28, 2011, L-3 Communications Holdings Inc. (NYSE: LLL) announced that its Board of Directors had approved a plan to spin off part of its Government Services unit, to be named Engility Holdings Inc., to shareholders in a tax-free distribution scheduled for 1H 2012. Businesses that will be spun off include L-3’s systems engineering and technical support as well as training and operational support services for the Department of Defense, other US government agencies, and other civil and international clients. L-3’s cyber solutions business will remain a part of the parent. The spin-off will comprise most of the businesses directly affected by the expected decline in active combat troops, as training and operational support services would appear far more exposed to impending US military spending cuts.
L-3’s more growth-oriented businesses will stay with the parent. Homeland security, intelligence, and cyber-security programs would seem to remain government spending priorities. Intelligence-related operations will account for roughly 12% of post-spin parent revenue. Following the transaction, L-3 should have a much stronger growth and margin profile. L-3 has underperformed its peer group of large US defense contractors over the previous 12 months and currently trades at lower multiples than the group. Management likely expects the spin-off to result in a higher valuation multiple for the parent that is more in line with that of peers.
L-3 expects that Engility will pay a dividend of $500-$650 million to the parent and carry debt/EBITDA in the range of 3x-4x. L-3 could use the cash for acquisitions to increase exposure to faster-growing non-commoditized electronics businesses. The transaction still requires final Board approval and a positive IRS ruling on the tax-free nature of the spin-off, as well as Department of Defense and SEC approval. The Department of Defense is likely to carefully consider the debt level placed on the spin-off to ensure that the entity will be able to continue as a going concern in a shifting Pentagon spending environment.
If one assumes L-3 receives a multiple in line with the peer group in terms of earnings and free cash flow, a fair value estimate of $74 per share can be reached, above the current price of pre-spin L-3. As a result, investors would receive the spin-off for free. Nevertheless, given that the defense industry is currently in a period of significant flux, relying too heavily on comparables to reach a fair value could be short sighted. Peer group multiples have declined precipitously over the past 18 months, and there certainly can be further multiple compression, as competition for new contract awards as well as re-competes should result in significant pricing pressure.
An investor may consider a pair trade or taking a counter position on a group of DoD contract-reliant companies as protection against downside risk from future weakness in defense spending. Given the long cycles of the industry, barring unforeseen international incidents, global troop levels going forward seem likely to remain well below levels of the previous decade. One might choose to buy L-3 ahead of a transaction that appears destined to unlock shareholder value, but consideration of ongoing industry weakness should be factored into a purchasing decision.
One may take some comfort in L-3’s healthy free cash flow generation. Over the last three years, the company has used funds from operations to aggressively buy back stock. As capital expenditures would appear limited over the next few years, one might expect management to continue to buy back shares or consider raising the dividend. Share repurchases in 2010-2011 totaled almost $1.8 billion; in addition, the company paid out $372 million in dividends. Guidance for 2012 includes up to $800 million in buybacks, which is about 11% of the company’s market value, and $190 million for dividends. Given management’s willingness to support the stock and reward shareholders, owners of the stock could be well positioned if and when a defense industry recovery begins. With fewer shares outstanding, net income improvement would be magnified at the per share level. Notably, however, the long defense industry cycles could require significant patience.