Stewart Information Services Corp. (NYSE: STC) is a title insurer and real estate information provider headquartered in Houston, Texas. Despite a recent return to profitability, the company currently trades at less than 0.6x book value, a multiple that represents a discount relative to comparable companies. Although it could be argued that the current valuation of the consolidated company is attractive in its own right based on the discount to book value, Stewart Information Services’ (‘Stewart’) valuation appears even more attractive when analyzed on a sum-of-the-parts basis, much like other title insurance companies that have recently spun off their information services operations. Investors who value these two businesses separately will find that Stewart’s fair value in today’s market is nearly 50% higher than the company’s current share price. Therefore, shares of Stewart Information Services are recommended for purchase.
As with the rest of the title insurance industry, Stewart’s title business has seen revenues decline in recent years due to the lower levels of activity in the real estate market. Stewart also fell victim to the significant increases in its title insurance loss experience, which, when combined with the depressed top line, led to substantial losses over the last three years. These losses, however, appear to be behind the company, as Stewart has aggressively cut costs and has started to see insurance losses decline significantly from their peak. Further, the company does not expect to have any further reserve strengthening adjustments going forward, nor does it appear to have significant risk in its investment portfolio, which is invested primarily in the debt securities of various corporations and utilities and in foreign government bonds and treasuries.
The book value of Stewart’s title insurance business, as a stand-alone entity, is conservatively $385 million. Although it could be argued that a valuation on par with book value is warranted given the company’s return to profitability and the lower risk of declines in shareholders’ equity, other, arguably higher-quality comparables trade at a discount to book value. Therefore, if one assumed a valuation for Stewart’s title insurance business of 0.59x book value, which represents a 30% discount to First American Financial Corp. (NYSE: FAF), one would arrive at a valuation for this business of $227 million, which is nearly equivalent to the company’s current consolidated market capitalization. Under this scenario, therefore, investors are receiving the company’s real estate information business for free.
It is not surprising that Stewart’s information business is ignored, as this business accounts for less than 5% of the consolidated company’s revenues. This segment has significant value, however, having posted EBITDA of $15.4 million through the first six months of 2010. If one were to annualize this figure and attach a discounted EV/EBITDA multiple of 5.5x to the forecast EBITDA of $30.7 million, one would arrive at a fair value estimate of $155 million, which is more than 85% of the current enterprise value of $180 million for the consolidated company.
Stewart has a strong balance sheet, with a net cash position of $76.7 million, excluding non-controlling interests. Further, it finished 2009 with nearly $140 million of tax loss carry-forwards but has taken a valuation allowance against most of these losses. These valuation allowances can be evaluated for reversal as the company returns to profitability and should help Stewart accrue book value at a faster rate going forward as these assets help lower its effective tax rate. As a point of reference, if one adjusted the company’s current shareholders’ equity by adding back all $140 million of these tax loss carry-forwards, Stewart would be trading at 0.44x book value.
Lastly, Stewart should realize a higher level of earnings going forward, as it continues to aggressively manage expenses and as it sees its loss experience steadily (although most likely slowly) revert to the lower levels the title insurance industry has experienced historically. It should be noted that, even at their worst levels, losses in title insurance are well below those experienced in other lines of insurance, thus making significant further declines to book value unlikely.
Stewart has announced no plans to undertake the separation of its title insurance and real estate information business and one should not expect such a transaction to occur in the near future. It is evident, however, that the company is significantly undervalued relative to a sum-of-the-parts valuation of these two businesses, and a spin-off of Stewart’s information segment is a reasonable means for management to unlock the latent value currently residing within the company. Such a valuation shows that the fair value of the consolidated company is nearly $17 per share, or almost 50% higher than the current value of STC shares. As such, shares of Stewart Information Services are recommended for purchase.